We were visiting our daughter who lives in MKE, so we only used this place for parking and sleeping - while cooking, eating, and hanging out at her place. The parking was great, the bed was comfy (once I fixed the loose bedframe), and I really liked the towels they had for us. There was also a really nice coffee machine. However, the place is part of a house that has multiple apartments. It's an old house and while the "bungalo" served our purpose, you just can't overcome some of the quirks that an old, divided house like this has.
Windows that don't lock (kitchen) or close (living room - it was winter, so there was a cold breeze when I was sitting on the couch), no light near the bathroom mirror (shaving was a bit of a challenge with the ceiling light behind me), and *really* inconvenient light switch placement (I know, it sounds trivial... but nothing to turn on when you first walk in at night... behind the bathroom door... A bit of a challenge in the dark.)
I felt like they were just getting the place converted from an unrented apartment to a VRBO, so there were a few things lacking for a more involved stay. If you are planning on cooking there, you may need some additional cooking utensils, dish towels, and silverware - that sort of thing. Maybe check back later and they will have a more complete setup.
The location was great if you wanted to hit the nightlife on Brady St. and other than the heater (which was pretty loud and woke us up when it turned on) it was quiet despite the busy nightlife just up the road.
Even though we didn't need to use it for food storage, I don't think it helped that there were some leftover condiments and a half drank Pepsi in the fridge - it just didn't feel to have the same quality or preparation as other VRBOs we've rented in the past. It worked out for our needs (mainly parking, a place to shower, and a bed), but if I had known this was going to have such a "off campus college housing" feel, I would have stayed in a different place.